Shahzad Bhatti Welcome to my ramblings and rants!

January 1, 2023

Consumer-driven and Producer-generated Contract Testing for REST APIs

Filed under: REST,Testing,Web Services — admin @ 9:43 pm

Though, REST standard for remote APIs is fairly loose but you can document API shape and structure using standards such as Open API and swagger specifications. The documented API specification ensures that both consumer/client and producer/server side abide by the specifications and prevent unexpected behavior. The API provider may also define service-level objective (SLO) so that API meets specified latency, security and availability and other service-level indicators (SLI). The API provider can use contract tests to validate the API interactions based on documented specifications. The contract testing includes both consumer and producer where a consumer makes an API request and the producer produces the result. The contract tests ensures that both consumer requests and producer responses match the contract request and response definitions per API specifications. These contract tests don’t just validate API schema instead they validate interactions between consumer and producer thus they can also be used to detect any breaking or backward incompatible changes so that consumers can continue using the APIs without any surprises.

In order to demonstrate contract testing, we will use api-mock-service library to generate mock/stub client requests and server responses based on Open API specifications or customized test contracts. These test contracts can be used by both consumers and producers for validating API contracts and evolve the contract tests as API specifications are updated.

Sample REST API Under Test

A sample eCommerce application will be used to demonstrate contracts testing. The application will use various REST APIs to implement online shopping experience. The primary purpose of this example is to show how different request structures can be passed to the REST APIs and then generate a valid result or an error condition for contract testing. You can view the Open-API specifications for this sample app here.

Customer REST APIs

The customer APIs define operations to manage customers who shop online, e.g.:

Customer APIs

Product REST APIs

The product APIs define operations to manage products that can be shopped online, e.g.:

Product APIs

Payment REST APIs

The payment APIs define operations to charge credit card and pay for online shopping, e.g.:

Payment APIs

Order REST APIs

The order APIs define operations to purchase a product from the online store and it will use above APIs to validate customers, check product inventory, charge payments and then store record of orders, e.g.:

Order APIs

Generating Stub Server Responses based on Open-API Specifications

In this example, stub server responses will be generated by api-mock-service based on open-api specifications ecommerce-api.json by starting the mock service first as follows:

Shell

And then uploading open-API specifications for ecommerce-api.json:

Shell

It will generate test contracts with stub/mock responses for all APIs defined in the ecommerce-api.json Open API specification. For example, you can produce result of customers REST APIs, e.g.:

Shell

to produce:

JSON

Above response is randomly generated based on the types/formats/regex/min-max limits of properties defined in Open-API and calling this API will automatically generate all valid and error responses, e.g. calling “curl http://localhost:8000/customers” again will return:

JSON

Consumer-driven Contract Testing

Upon uploading the Open-API specifications of microservices, the api-mock-service generates test contracts for each REST API and response statuses. You can then customize these test cases for consumer-driven contract testing.

For example, here is the default test contract generated for finding a customer by id with path “/customers/:id”:

YAML

Above template demonstrates interaction between consumer and producer by defining properties such as:

  • method – of REST API such as GET/POST/PUT/DELETE
  • name – of the test case
  • path of REST API
  • description – of test
  • predicate – defines a condition which must be true to select this test contract
  • request section defines input properties for the REST API including:
    • match_query_params – to match query input parameters for selecting the test contract
    • match_headers – to match input headers for selecting the test contract
    • match_contents – defines regex for selecting input body
    • path_params – defines path variables and regex
    • query_params and headers – defines sample input parameters and headers
  • response section defines output properties for the REST API including:
    • headers – defines response headers
    • contents – defines body of response
    • contents_file – allows loading response from a file
    • status_code – defines HTTP response status
  • wait_before_reply – defines wait time before returning response

You can then invoke test contract using:

Shell

that generates test case from the mock/stub server provided by the api-mock-service library, e.g.

JSON

You can customize above response contents using builtin template functions in the api-mock-service library or create additional test contracts for each distinct input parameter. For example, following contract defines interaction between consumer and producer to add a new customer:

YAML

Above template defines interaction for adding a new customer where request section defines format of request and matching criteria using match_content property. The response section includes the headers and contents that are generated by the stub/mock server for consumer-driven contract testing. You can then invoke test contract using:

Shell

Which will return a response such as:

JSON

Note: The response will not match the request body as the contract testing only tests interactions between consumer and producer without maintaining any server side state. You can use other types of testing such as integration/component/functional testing for validating state based behavior.

Producer-driven Generated Tests

The process of defining contracts to generate tests for validating producer REST APIs is similar to consumer-driven contracts. For example, you can upload open-api specifications or user-defined contracts to the api-mock-service provided mock/stub server.

For example, you can upload open-API specifications for ecommerce-api.json as follows:

Shell

Upon uploading the specifications, the mock server will generate contracts for each REST API and status. You can customize those contracts with additional validation or assertion and then invoke server generated tests either by specifying the REST API or invoke multiple REST APIs belonging to a specific group. You can also define an order for executing tests in a group and can optionally pass data from one invocation to the next invocation of REST API.

For testing purpose, we will customize customer REST APIs for adding a new customer and fetching a customer by its id, i.e.,

A contract for adding a new customer

YAML

The request section defines content property that will build the input request, which will be sent to the producer provided REST API. The server section defines match_contents to match regex of each response property. In addition, the response section defines assertions to compare against response contents, headers or status against expected output.

A contract for finding an existing customer

YAML

Above template defines similar properties to generate request body and defines match_contents with assertions to match expected output headers, body and status. Based on order of tests, the generated test to add new customer will be executed first, which will be followed by the test to find a customer by id. As we are testing against real REST APIs, the REST API path is defined as “/customers/{{.id}}” for finding a customer will populate the id from the output of first test based on the pipe_properties.

Uploading Contracts

Once you have the api-mock-service mock server running, you can upload contracts using:

Shell

You can start your service before invoking generated tests, e.g. we will use sample-openapi for the testing purpose and then invoke the generated tests using:

Shell

Above command will execute all tests for customers group and it will invoke each REST API 5 times. After executing the APIs, it will generate result as follows:

JSON

Though, generated tests are executed against real services, it’s recommended that the service implementation use test doubles or mock services for any dependent services as contract testing is not meant to replace component or end-to-end tests that provide better support for integration testing.

Recording Consumer/Producer interactions for Generating Stub Requests and Responses

The contract testing does not always depend on API specifications such as Open API and swagger and instead you can record interactions between consumers and producers using api-mock-service tool.

For example, if you have an existing REST API or a legacy service such as above sample API, you can record an interaction as follows:

Shell

This will invoke the remote REST API, record contract interactions and then return server response:

JSON

The recorded contract can be used to generate the stub response, e.g. following configuration defines the recorded contract:

YAML

You can then invoke consumer-driven contracts to generate stub response or invoke generated tests to test against producer implementation as described in earlier section. Another benefit of capturing test contracts using recorded session is that it can accurately capture all URLs, parameters and headers for both requests and responses so that contract testing can precisely validate against existing behavior.

Summary

Though, unit-testing, component testing and end-to-end testing are a common testing strategies that are used by most organizations but they don’t provide adequate support to validate API specifications and interactions between consumers/clients and producers/providers of the APIs. The contract testing ensures that consumers and producers will not deviate from the specifications and can be used to validate changes for backward compatibility when APIs are evolved. This also decouples consumers and producers if the API is still in development as both parties can write code against the agreed contracts and test them independently. A service owner can generate producer contracts using tools such as api-mock-service based on Open API specification or user-defined constraints. The consumers can provide their consumer-driven contracts to the service providers to ensure that the API changes don’t break any consumers. These contracts can be stored in a source code repository or on a registry service so that contract testing can easily access them and execute them as part of the build and deployment pipelines. The api-mock-service tool greatly assists in adding contract testing to your software development lifecycle and is freely available from https://github.com/bhatti/api-mock-service.

Powered by WordPress